Waretown, New Jersey
Cottrell's Seafood & Take Out brings the shore's freshest catches right to Main Street — daily specials, classic preparations, and a table waiting just for you.
Fresh Daily
Locally sourced catches
94 Main St
Waretown, NJ 08758
(609) 693-4052
Call for take out
Our Story
Nestled on Main Street in the heart of Waretown, Cottrell's Seafood & Take Out has been a steady, welcoming presence for locals and visitors alike. We believe the best seafood doesn't need pretense — just fresh catch, honest preparation, and a warm place to sit down.
Whether you're pulling in for a quick take out order after a day on the water or settling in for a leisurely meal with family, our kitchen puts the same care into every plate. No shortcuts. No filler. Just seafood done right.
100%
Fresh Catch
Daily
Specials
Take
Out Available
What We Serve
Our menu changes with the catch. Here are the staples you'll always find — and a few surprises waiting for you each day.
Starters
Creamy, smoky, and loaded with fresh clams. Served with a buttery roll.
Entrees
Beer-battered fillets, pickled cabbage, and chipotle crema in warm tortillas.
Raw Bar
Half dozen served on ice with mignonette, lemon, and cocktail sauce.
Entrees
Jumbo lump crab, lightly bound and pan-seared. A Maryland classic, done right.
Entrees
Stone-ground cheddar grits topped with Gulf shrimp, andouille, and a smoky gravy.
For Two
Fried shrimp, fish, clams, and crab cake — all the favorites on one board.
Menu items rotate with daily catches. Call ahead to check what's on deck today.
The Experience
We keep things simple. Walk in, grab a seat, and let the kitchen do the rest. Our dining room is relaxed and unpretentious — the kind of place where regulars know your name and newcomers feel at home by the second bite.
In a hurry? Call ahead and we'll have your take out ready when you pull into the parking lot. Same food, same care, zero wait.
Order take out or stop by for a seat at the counter. Either way, we'll have something fresh waiting.
(609) 693-4052